How to Become a Data-Driven Organisation: Strategies and Pitfalls to Avoid

TL;DR

Becoming a data-driven organisation is more than deploying analytics tools—it's about embedding data into decision-making at every level. In this post, we explore how to build a sustainable data strategy using the RICE framework—Reach, Impact, Confidence, and Effort—and how to avoid the most common transformation traps that derail progress.

Introduction: Data is the New Operating System

Organisations across all sectors are under pressure to modernise. Yet becoming truly data-driven remains elusive. Despite significant investments in business intelligence and data platforms, decision-making often still relies on instinct over insight.

So why do so many digital transformations falter?

Drawing from decades of leadership in global CIO roles across retail, engineering, and private equity-backed businesses, I’ve observed that the problem isn’t the technology—it's the approach.

Let’s explore how to truly become a data-driven organisation, and how to sidestep the traps I’ve seen derail even the most well-funded initiatives.

The RICE Framework for Becoming a Data-Driven Organisation

Transforming into a data-driven organisation requires a strategic framework. I use the RICE framework—Reach, Impact, Confidence, Effort—to prioritise, govern and embed change.

R — Reach: How Far Will the Data Go?

Start by assessing how widely data will influence your organisation.

• Will it guide board decisions?

• Will operational teams use it to adjust supply chain forecasts?

• Will HR optimise recruitment based on predictive analytics?

Common Pitfall: Focusing on isolated data projects (e.g. marketing dashboards) with little business integration.

Tip: Use a data strategy roadmap that spans all departments, aligning data projects with strategic objectives.

I — Impact: What Business Value Will This Deliver?

Every data initiative should clearly map to business KPIs: cost reduction, revenue growth, customer retention, or compliance.

Real-World Example: At a manufacturing firm I advised, embedding Power BI dashboards across 13 global sites reduced technical debt by £2 million in under a year.

Common Pitfall: Measuring vanity metrics that don’t drive value.

Tip: Create impact hypotheses for each data project, and test against measurable business outcomes.

C — Confidence: Can You Trust Your Data?

Trust in data quality is foundational. Without robust data governance, even the best analytics platforms will fail to drive adoption.

Case Study: I’ve seen organisations with ERP systems like SAP or Oracle struggle because of poor data integration across finance, retail, and operations. The fix? Establishing a data governance board with accountability baked into each business function.

Common Pitfall: Assuming the IT department owns all data quality issues.

Tip: Assign data stewards across the business. Make data governance a shared responsibility.

E — Effort: What Will it Take to Embed This Culturally?

This is the human side of transformation. Becoming a data-driven organisation is as much about change management as it is about technology.

Insight: At Northumbrian Water, implementing RPA and AI saved 75,000 hours annually and removed 50 FTEs—but only after extensive stakeholder engagement and upskilling.

Common Pitfall: Believing a new platform alone will “create” a data culture.

Tip: Invest in training, change agents, and internal comms. Data literacy must be democratised—not centralised.

How to Avoid the 5 Most Common Pitfalls

1. “Technology First” Mindset

Technology is an enabler—not the goal. Begin with why, then decide how.

2. Lack of Executive Ownership

Your C-suite must not only sponsor but also use data in decisions. Without visible leadership, cultural adoption stalls.

3. Overengineering the Solution

Over-complex solutions (think multi-platform integrations and endless KPIs) lead to fatigue and disengagement.

4. Ignoring Data Ethics and Privacy

With GDPR and rising scrutiny, data misuse can erode trust fast. Embed privacy by design.

5. Forgetting About Scalability

Design for scale from the outset. Data demands grow exponentially as you mature.

Final Thoughts: Data Culture Eats Data Strategy for Breakfast

You can’t buy a data culture. You must build it—across leadership, processes, tools, and talent.

In my advisory roles, I’ve helped global firms re-platform ERP systems, deploy AI-driven analytics, and create lasting change. The lesson? Becoming data-driven isn’t an event—it’s a journey.

Start small. Align to impact. Build trust. And above all, don’t make it an IT project—it’s a business transformation.

FAQs

What is a data-driven organisation?

A data-driven organisation uses data to guide decisions at every level, embedding insights into operations, strategy, and customer engagement.

Why do data transformation projects fail?

Most fail due to poor leadership alignment, lack of data governance, unclear business impact, or inadequate change management.

How long does it take to become data-driven?

Typically 12–36 months depending on maturity, investment, and organisational readiness.

What tools help in becoming data-driven?

Platforms like Power BI, Tableau, Snowflake, and cloud ERP solutions (SAP, Oracle, NetSuite) are valuable—but tools only support the journey.

In Closing

Data will not drive your business—people using data will. Start with a strong strategy, engage your people, and focus on delivering meaningful impact.

Richard Keenlyside is a Global CIO, PE&MA Advisor, Endava TAC and a former IT Director for J Sainsbury’s PLC.

Call me on +44(0) 1642 040 268 or email richard@rjk.info.

With over 1000+ subscribers join my newsletter today: https://www.rjk.info/newsletter-and-social-updates.

Follow me on X https://x.com/cioinpractice & LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/richardkeenlyside/